blog logo image

Posts Tagged ‘developing world’

MFAN Partner Responds to Foreign Assistance Dashboard

Thursday, January 6th, 2011
Bookmark and Share

Rolled out a day after the Quadrennial Diplomacy and Development Review (QDDR) in December, the Foreign Assistance Dashboard is starting to generate some serious buzz. MFAN Co-Chairs David Beckmann and George Ingram stated the dashboard “is a concrete sign that the Obama Administration is moving forward to implement the reforms.” In a piece titled “Foreign Assistance Dashboard:  Helping Achieve a Rights-Based Approach to Development,” the Robert F. Kennedy Center for Justice and Human Rights notes the dominate role transparency plays in ensuring effective development that includes an emphasis on human rights. See the full guest post below:

rfk logoThe new Foreign Assistance Dashboard is an important step forward for improving transparency in U.S. foreign assistance.  This innovative tool will increase the potential for aid effectiveness and respect of human rights.  Transparency is a core element of a human rights-based approach to development, along with accountability, non-discrimination, and participation.  The human rights- based approach seeks to empower beneficiaries of aid to claim the rights that every human is entitled to.  Increased access to information is the linchpin of a rights-based approach, providing improved opportunities for community participation, ownership, and accountability.

The work of the RFK Center for Justice & Human Rights with Zanmi Lasante in Haiti over the last eight years has demonstrated that impacted communities tend to be the last to know critical details of planned international interventions.  Communities may not be informed of project plans or how to seek redress for any problems that arise.  The increased transparency from the Dashboard will allow those with internet access to gain important information, but it is necessary that information is made accessible in a variety of ways appropriate to each context, including multiple languages and formats.  This will provide these communities, as well as their respective governments, the information needed to participate in the consultation, design, and implementation process—which will increase country ownership and lead to more successful and sustainable program outcomes.

While the United States continues to provide large amounts of assistance in much-needed areas, both geographically and across sectors, it has always been difficult to trace this funding to concrete on-the-ground results.  In order to truly be effective and follow a rights-based approach to increase participation and accountability, the Dashboard should not only link appropriations to specific projects, but also include more detailed information on foreign assistance activities. This includes timely qualitative and quantitative data, such as project timelines, design and implementation plans, targets, benchmarks, redress mechanisms, opportunities for community members to get involved, implementing partners, and local points of contact for each U.S. government funded project. Inclusion of this data will give beneficiaries of aid the information necessary to make sure assistances is responsive to their needs. The Dashboard provides users with the capability to submit feedback and ask questions about the functioning of the site; however, what is more important for accountability would be the opportunity for impacted individuals to provide feedback on specific projects and a mechanism to be in places to provide redress if harm has been caused.   In addition, information about regional strategies should be provided and funding streams should be linked to these strategies to demonstrate how funds will contribute to long-term goals, as well as allow the international community to determine whether it has achieved its intended goal, leading to increased accountability from both the U.S. government and recipient governments.

The RFK Center has long called for a tracking system such as the Foreign Assistance Dashboard and increased efforts toward aid effectiveness, and welcomes its launch. However further expansion and detail is needed to fully embody a human rights-based approach.  As transparency increases, the U.S. government and tax-payers will be able to evaluate the strengths and weaknesses of foreign assistance projects more objectively and thoroughly, while recipients will finally have the information needed to actively participate in the development of their country.

MFAN Partners React to QDDR Release

Thursday, December 16th, 2010
Bookmark and Share

Below are excerpts from MFAN Partners’ statements in reaction to the release of the first-ever Quadrennial Diplomacy and Development Review (QDDR) yesterday.  Stay tuned for press coverage of the rollout.

breadMFAN Co-Chair and President of Bread for the World Rev. David Beckmann stated, “The QDDR is an important step in reforming U.S. foreign aid, making U.S. support for development and poverty reduction around the world more effective,” said Rev. David Beckmann, president of Bread for the World. “This is yet another way the administration is showing its dedication to providing effective assistance to people all over the world who desperately need it.”

Sam Worthington, MFAN Principal and President and CEO of InterAction, noted, “QDDR is more than just an acronym. This reviewInteractionseeks to use aid and diplomacy more effectively in order to streamline and better coordinate development to meet our national interests,” said Samuel A. Worthington, president of InterAction, the largest alliance of U.S.-based international NGOs. “We urge Congress to support the many positive changes being proposed and to provide the necessary resources for USAID and the State Department as they implement a new, more effective, approach to global development.”

ONEMFAN Principal and ONE CEO David Lane said, “In tough fiscal times, the business of development must be reformed to make the most of every dollar that America invests to help the world’s poorest. It must also increase transparency and improve governance so that progress is sustainable. The reforms outlined in the QDDR, in addition to ongoing efforts like USAID Forward, are central to making America’s development business model better.”Oxfam

Oxfam America’s Paul O’ Brien, vice president of policy and advocacy campaigns, commented, “The QDDR is animportant step in reaffirming the efforts to modernize USAID and further elevate it as ‘the world’s premier development agency.  But the document leaves open the question of how the United States will resolve situations where diplomacy and development will require different approaches and tradeoffs.”

USGLCMFAN Principal and Executive Director of the U.S. Global Leadership Coalition Liz Schrayer said, “The QDDR represents a bold step towards implementing a smart power foreign policy by elevating our civilian power and ensuring effective, results-driven programs,” said USGLC Executive Director Liz Schrayer.  “This review can help ensure international affairs programs continue to make a critical impact in advancing our national security and economic interests.”

Women Thrive Worldwide logoMFAN Principal Ritu Sharma, President and Co-founder of Women Thrive Worldwide, noted, “This common-sense approach is a fundamental game-changer for millions of women and girls in villages around the world. What this means is that all programs that the U.S. implements moving forward, worth tens of billions of dollars, have to take the needs and voices of women and girls into account. We have long advocated a move beyond the special, small, separate women’s projects.”

MFAN Partner Oxfam on the New US Foreign Assistance Dashboard

Thursday, December 16th, 2010
Bookmark and Share

See below for a guest post from MFAN member Archana Palaniappan of the Aid Effectiveness Team at Oxfam America as she highlights features of the new US Foreign Assistance Dashboard, which launched today. The dashboard is just one of the changes brought on by the Quadrennial Diplomacy and Development Review (QDDR) and internal reforms at USAID–USAID Forward.

This is actually useful:  The new US Foreign Assistance Dashboard

Have you checked out foreignassistance.gov yet?  I know, another government data website might not seem like your idea of a gift from Santa.  But actually, this has the capacity to save development nerds a lot of time and has the potential to help poor people solve a lot of headaches.

The new website is commonly referred to as the “Aid Dashboard.”  It’s the follow-through on a promise made in July when the Obama Administration unveiled its plan to meet the Millennium Development Goals by 2015.  The Aid Dashboard aims to give the public a window into how and where US development dollars are spent.  And it’s not just a mash of numbers; the Dashboard uses dynamic graphics to allow stakeholders to picture US foreign assistance investments easily by geography, sector, or time period.

So is this a big deal to poor people?  The more people in poor countries know what donors are up to in their own backyards, the more they can hold their governments responsible for how they use the aid money that comes in. Citizen watchdog groups, journalists, and local businesses alike can use this comprehensive information to blow the whistle on aid dollars that they now know disappeared or weren’t used to meet their needs.  The more citizens know, the more they can fight corruption themselves.

I’m really excited that the United States is finally taking aid transparency seriously. It’s no small task trying to get all 26 US agencies that deliver foreign aid on the same page (note that’s the end goal ─ the beta version today only includes spending by USAID and the State Department).  But this is just a first step. I’m still left wondering about the people this would matter to the most.  How user-friendly is this data to aid recipients and does it answer “what they’re asking for?”

Magalie L’Abbé under a Creative Commons licenseIn a country like Cambodia, where foreign aid accounts for half the national budget, will this online tool help their citizens?  Consider that less than 2 percent of the population can access the internet and read English. Outside of the government, there are probably only ten people who can access the database and analyze it.  To the average Cambodian, that’s not transparency yet.  But they’ve taken the first step.  Now it’s up to the US embassies and USAID mission staff in-country to disseminate the information in a more accessible form.  But do they have the mandate and capacity to translate the information into local languages? Will they do extensive outreach with local civil society organizations, budget monitoring groups, legislatures, and supreme auditing bodies?  Most importantly, what’s their incentive to report to the country and even give data to the country’s own aid information management system?  The information is only as good as it is useable.  Just a few more steps to take and we can magnify anti-corruption efforts by citizens around the world.

Monks head online in Phnom Penh.Photo courtesy of Flickr user Magalie L’Abbé under a Creative Commons license.

The Aid Dashboard is a good start and I hope to see its longevity cemented by Congress.  They have the power to make it stick, and in fact, various bipartisan bills with broad support have already called for more transparency of US aid dollars.  Seems like a no-brainer.  Over the next year, USAID and State are road testing the Aid Dashboard in three highly aid dependent countries to learn what information is the most valuable to those countries.  In the meantime, the creators are eager to get feedback on this work-in-progress.  Be sure to click on the site’s Contact Us tab and let them know how to improve the data they provide so it can help citizens control their own development.

To learn more about what the lack of transparency means on the ground, check out Oxfam’s report, Information:  Let Countries Know What Donors Are Doing.  And remember kids, the more you know, the more you can do.

MFAN Statement: QDDR Paves Way for Real Reform

Wednesday, December 15th, 2010
Bookmark and Share

December 15, 2010 (WASHINGTON)This statement is delivered on behalf of the Modernizing Foreign Assistance Network (MFAN) by Co-Chairs David Beckmann and George Ingram:

With today’s release of the first-ever Quadrennial Diplomacy and Development Review (QDDR), the Obama Administration has finalized its roadmap for how U.S. foreign aid can be made more effective, efficient, and accountable in the 21st century.  This is absolutely critical in a resource-constrained world where our efforts to save lives and help vulnerable people build their own livelihoods are as important as our military and diplomatic activities.

Secretary Clinton, Administrator Shah and all the professionals who worked on the QDDR at the State Department, the United States Agency for International Development (USAID), and elsewhere across the government deserve enormous credit.  We are particularly pleased that the QDDR:

  • Strengthens the position of development as a core pillar of U.S. foreign policy and sets the stage for civilian development professionals to play a leadership role in America’s global engagement.
  • Institutes changes that will bring clearer lines of authority and responsibility for results to our marquee development programs, by putting USAID’s development experts in the lead on programs like Feed the Future and the Global Health Initiative; giving the agency a stronger voice in the interagency policymaking process; and making USAID Chiefs of Mission the lead development advisors to U.S. Ambassadors in the field.
  • Strengthens monitoring and evaluation of development programs and makes future funding of such programs contingent on real results.
  • Places an emphasis on helping recipient countries take ownership of their own development.
  • Brings more transparency to development programs, including by instituting long-term development planning for recipient countries and launching a new web-based dashboard where the public can see how U.S. foreign assistance is delivering results.

These reforms would pay major dividends in terms of lives saved and improved around the world – and they would make sure that U.S. taxpayer dollars are getting into the hands of people who need them.  But they will only have lasting impact if the Administration and bipartisan Members of Congress work together to develop and pass legislation that establishes them in law.  We look forward to working with the Administration and Members of Congress on this legislation, and we stand ready to make sure the reforms are implemented effectively and transparently.

QDDR Executive Summary

Wednesday, December 15th, 2010
Bookmark and Share

The first-ever Quadrennial Diplomacy and Development Review (QDDR) is now ready for your comments, courtesy of MFAN Partner InterAction’s QDDR Page. Before diving into the full 200-page report (awaiting release), we recommend taking a look at the Executive Summary which states:

“These civilians ask one question again and again: How can we do a better job of advancing the interests of the American people? The answer should be the same for every agency and department: We can work smarter and better by setting clear priorities, managing for results, holding ourselves accountable, and unifying our efforts. The first-ever Quadrennial Diplomacy and Development Review (QDDR) aims to meet these goals by setting forth a sweeping reform agenda for the State Department and USAID, the lead agencies for foreign relations and development respectively. It follows in the footsteps of the quadrennial reviews by the Departments of Defense and Homeland Security in taking a comprehensive look at how we can spend our resources most efficiently, how we can achieve our priorities most effectively, what we should be doing differently, and how we should prepare ourselves for the world ahead.”

Stay tuned for more as we take a deeper dive into the development elements of the QDDR.